Porcelain vs Ceramic Tile: Differences and Where to Use Each

By

in

·

Porcelain is a type of ceramic tile. What makes it porcelain is a test, not a name: under the US standard ANSI A137.1, a tile is porcelain only if it absorbs 0.5% of its weight in water or less when tested to ASTM C373. That density makes porcelain tougher, more water-resistant and more suitable for outdoor use, but also heavier and harder to cut. Non-porcelain ceramic tile absorbs more water, is easier to cut and works well for walls and most indoor floors.

Whichever you choose, the tile calculator gives the number of tiles and boxes, including waste for your layout.

Porcelain vs ceramic at a glance

Porcelain tileCeramic (non-porcelain) tile
Water absorption0.5% or less (ANSI A137.1)Above 0.5%; wall tile can be above 7%
BodyDense; through-body porcelain has the same color throughoutSofter body under a glaze, often a different color
Typical wear ratingMany are PEI 4 or 5 (glazed)Often PEI 0 to 3
FloorsAll residential floors, including entries and kitchensCheck PEI rating; class 3 or higher for normal floors
Showers and wet areasWell suitedFine on walls; for floors choose a rating made for floors
Outdoors, freezing climatesCan be suitable if rated frost resistantUsually not suitable
CuttingHarder; needs a good cutter or wet sawEasier to score and snap
WeightHeavier for the same sizeLighter
Ratings vary by product; check the box or spec sheet.

Water absorption classes

Tile is grouped by how much water it absorbs. Lower absorption means a denser tile that stands up better to moisture and freezing.

ClassWater absorptionTypical use
Impervious (porcelain)0.5% or lessFloors, wet areas, outdoors where rated
VitreousOver 0.5% to 3%Floors and some exterior uses
Semi-vitreousOver 3% to 7%Indoor floors and walls
Non-vitreousOver 7%Indoor walls
Classes as described in the Home Depot tile guide; porcelain threshold per ANSI A137.1.

For patios and other outdoor tile in freezing climates, frost resistance requires vitreous or impervious tile. Even then, no tile is freeze-proof: the tile must be rated for freeze-thaw use (tested to ASTM C1026) and installed so water drains away.

PEI ratings: how hard-wearing is the glaze?

PEI classSuitable for
1Walls only
2Walls and bathroom floors
3Walls, countertops and floors with normal foot traffic
4All residential use, plus medium commercial
5All residential use, plus heavy commercial
PEI rates the abrasion resistance of glazed tile. Summary from Dal-Tile via NKBA.

PEI and porcelain answer different questions. Water absorption says how dense the body is; PEI says how well the glazed surface resists wear. A ceramic tile can have a good PEI rating, and a porcelain wall tile can have a low one, so check both for floors.

Which should you choose?

  • Bathroom and kitchen walls, backsplashes: either. Ceramic is easier to cut around outlets and fixtures.
  • Bathroom floors and showers: porcelain, or ceramic rated for floors (PEI 2 or higher for bathrooms, 3 or higher for busier rooms).
  • Kitchens, entries, hallways: porcelain or ceramic with PEI 3 or higher.
  • Outdoors and unheated spaces in cold climates: porcelain rated frost resistant.
  • DIY on a budget: ceramic is lighter and easier to cut, which helps if you do not own a wet saw.

Installing porcelain

Because porcelain absorbs so little, the setting mortar has to grip a very dense surface. Use a thin-set mortar whose bag says it is suitable for porcelain tile, and follow its trowel size for your tile size. The thinset calculator and grout calculator give the number of bags, and tile layout patterns and waste explains how much extra to buy.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell porcelain from ceramic?

Check the box or spec sheet for water absorption of 0.5% or less, or a porcelain certification mark. Looking at a chipped edge helps with through-body porcelain, but glazed porcelain can also have a different-colored body.

Is porcelain always better?

Not always. It is better where water, wear or freezing matter. On walls, ceramic does the job, costs less to install and is easier to work with.

Is porcelain more expensive?

Prices overlap widely by product, size and finish. Compare specific tiles, and add the cost of a wet saw rental and porcelain-rated mortar to the porcelain option. The project cost calculator adds up the materials for each choice.

Sources